Luxembourg-Based JAB Holding Co. Affirmed At #BBB+# On Definitive Agreement To Acquire Panera Outlook Stable

Stocks and Financial Services Press Releases Tuesday April 11, 2017 17:47
PARIS--11 Apr--S&P Global Ratings
PARIS (S&P Global Ratings) April 11, 2017--S&P Global Ratings today affirmed its 'BBB+' long-term corporate credit rating on Luxembourg-based JAB Holding Company S.a.r.l. (JAB). The outlook is stable.
We also affirmed our 'BBB+' issue ratings on JAB's senior unsecured debt issued by JAB Holdings B.V. and guaranteed by JAB.
The affirmation follows JAB's announcement that it would lead a consortium to acquire 100% of Panera Bread in a take-private transaction for a total consideration of approximately $7.5 billion.

Panera Bread is a U.S.-based retail bakery-cafe company chiefly focusing on the U.S. market through its 2,000 store network and a minor presence in Canada. In 2016, the group generated just under $3 billion in revenues and reported EBITDA of $430 million.

We understand this proposed transaction will be financed through debt at Panera's level, and contributions from JAB, JAB Consumer Funds, and other investors. This type of financing is fairly similar to the one that JAB undertook less than 12 months ago for the $13.5 billion Keurig Green Mountain (KGM) acquisition. We think JAB's still-undisclosed contribution will be financed through a combination of cash and further drawing on its €2.6 billion existing lines due 2021. Despite the debt increase, we expect the loan-to-value (LTV) ratio to be sufficiently near our threshold for the rating of 20% or marginally above it for only a short period of time. If needed, we expect management will consider assets sales and use the proceeds to lower the LTV ratio. With a portfolio valued at about €21 billion as of April 10, 2017, which compares with net debt of €3.6 billion at year-end 2016, JAB currently enjoys very limited flexibility for further acquisitions. As per our calculations, and based upon current market prices, the company can accommodate a net debt increase of only €800 million before its LTV ratio increases from 17% to 20%.

We view the proposed acquisition as relatively aggressive, given the price of more than 17x EBITDA (year-end 2016), which represents a 30% premium versus the 30-day average share price as of March 31, 2017.
Some execution risk remains, with only 15.5% of the shareholders' approval secured at this stage through the voting agreement the founder has entered.

Should JAB complete this transaction, our view of its business risk profile would, however, weaken, since we believe both asset liquidity and quality have deteriorated lately. The average credit quality of JAB's portfolio has recently been impaired by Reckitt Benckiser undertaking a $17.9 billion debt-funded acquisition of Mead Johnson, which resulted in our downgrading Reckitt Benckiser to 'A-' from 'A+' (see "Consumer Health Group Reckitt Benckiser Downgraded To 'A-/A-2' On Agreement To Acquire Mead Johnson; Outlook Stable," published March 15, 2017, on RatingsDirect).

Additionally, Coty's share price underperformed due to challenging integration of the P&G Beauty Business, and JAB's listed assets further decreased to less than 50% of the portfolio as of April 10, 2017.

JAB's significant involvement in its core assets further weighs on our liquidity assessments, since this could undermine their immediate tradability, in our view. Such unsupportive developments were somewhat mitigated by KGM's improved creditworthiness (see "Keurig Green Mountain Inc. Upgraded To 'BB' From 'BB-'; Outlook Stable; Issue-Level Rating Actions Taken," published Jan. 26, 2017); Reckitt Benckiser and Coty maintaining their dividend policies; and continuous deleveraging of other key operating assets, including JACOBS DOUWE EGBERTS International B.V. (JDE), Peets, and Caribou Coffee, although uneven by operating assets.

We think Panera fits well in the group's investment portfolio by complimenting its €2 billion retail coffee adjacency assets, notably retail restaurants Caribou Coffee, Einstein Noah, and Peets. It will provide some portfolio diversification without necessarily impacting the weight of the top three assets, which have already improved since the KGM integration (representing about 60% compared to more than 80% at year-end 2015).

We think that JAB would structure Panera's funding in a moderately aggressive way, in line with the leverage of other operating assets in the portfolio; we anticipate adjusted debt-to-EBITDA ratios in the range of 3.5x-5.0x for Coty, Keurig, and JDE by year-end 2017. Consequently, we anticipate average asset quality will deteriorate to the 'BB' category. However, this is subject to Panera's eventual weight in the overall portfolio value. We expect JAB's financial policy will remain conservative and that debt at Panera will remain nonrecourse to JAB's debt and not pose cross-default risk.

In our opinion, JAB's financial risk profile is supported by the management's ability to enhance the portfolio value with discipline, sustainably sticking to an LTV ratio of 20%. With the integration of new portfolio lines being accompanied by the contribution from JAB Consumer Fund, the holding can retain its spending while maintaining an LTV ratio in line with 20%. If the LTV ratio exceeds 20% upon closing of the transaction, we would expect management to take action to restore it to the level required for the current rating.

JAB favorably compares with a number of other investment holding companies with no debt maturities within the next four years. What's more, the group has a track recording of maintaining cash flow coverage of at least 2x; pro forma Panera, we would expect some uplift in cash flow coverage.

The stable outlook reflects our expectation that upon closing of the Panera Bread transaction, JAB's LTV ratio will remain in line with the 20% threshold we deem commensurate with the current rating. While the LTV ratio could marginally exceed 20% for a short period, we expect management to be proactive and take appropriate measures, such as asset rotation, if needed. Since we consider that the current ratings cannot accommodate any more debt, we expect JAB will generally finance further significant acquisitions through disposals.

We could consider a negative rating action if JAB's LTV ratio rose above 20% for a prolonged period of time, without management taking actions to reduce it. Ratings pressure could be triggered in case of a material decline in JAB's equity values, or if its listed assets were below 60% of total assets for an extended period of time and absent clear commitment from management to consider asset monetization through an IPO within the next 18 to 24 months.

We consider ratings upside to be remote at this stage, since it would necessitate improvements in the portfolio's characteristics, including a greater emphasis on asset diversity and higher liquidity of held shares.

Assuming broadly unchanged portfolio characteristics, we could raise the ratings if JAB reduced leverage over time, and proved its commitment to an LTV ratio sustainably below 10% over our rating horizon.

Latest Press Release

mai welcomes real estate developer CMC on November 19

Market for Alternative Investment (mai) will list Chaoprayamahanakorn pcl, a leading real estate developer onNovember 19, under the ticker symbol "CMC". The company has a market capitalization at its initial public offering (IPO) of THB 3.00 billion...

KTC - Chilito Mexican Grill - Farm Factory provide members special privileges for payments made using QR Pay in the KTC Mobile app.

Mrs. Pranaya Nithananon, Vice President - Credit Card Business, "KTC" or Krungthai Card Public Company Limited, provides KTC VISA and KTC MasterCard credit card members who make payments through KTC QR Pay in the "KTC Mobile" app worth Bt. 300 or more...

Photo Release: KBank opens new flagship branch and THE WISDOM Lounge at ICONSIAM

Mr. Wirawat Panthawangkul (3rd from left), KBank Senior Executive Vice President, and Ms. Chadatip Chutrakul (4th from left), Director of ICONSIAM Co., Ltd., and Chief Executive Officer of Siam Piwat Co., Ltd., participated in the opening ceremony of...

Photo Release: CIMB Group Joins RippleNet to Power Instant Payments Across ASEAN

Tengku Dato' Sri Zafrul Aziz, Group CEO of CIMB Group (right), and Brad Garlinghouse, Ripple CEO (left) commemorating the strategic collaboration between CIMB Group and Ripple to power instant payments across ASEAN at the Singapore FinTech festival 2018...

CIMB Group Joins RippleNet to Power Instant Payments Across ASEAN

CIMB is one of the first banks to leverage blockchain technology to tap into region's USD120 billion remittance business CIMB Group ("CIMB" or "the Group") and Ripple have entered into a strategic collaboration to enable instant cross border payments...

Related Topics