On-premises vs. Cloud-managed WLAN: Which one to go for?

Information Technology Press Releases Tuesday November 5, 2019 17:02
Bangkok--5 Nov--Communication Arts

The dramatic emergence of smart devices is driving radical shifts in networking environments. Almost every device around our daily life – laptops, smartphones and tablets – is equipped with a wireless chipset that would find its way to connect to a network. Gartner, Inc. forecasts that the enterprise and automotive Internet of Things (IoT) market* will grow to 5.8 billion endpoints in 2020, a 21% increase from 2019. By the end of 2019, 4.8 billion endpoints are expected to be in use, up 21.5% from 2018. Today, Internet connectivity is expected to be as common as utilities like electricity.

In fact, the pervasiveness of mobility has sent the demand for enterprise-class wireless connections through the roof in many organizations. As many of these mobile devices rely on Wi-Fi to work and some of them have no wired fallback at all, the wireless network infrastructure must be fast, secure and highly reliable. Therefore, companies would have to look for options to support these users and to deliver stable connections with greater bandwidth and higher speed.

Evolution of WLAN Architecture

One of the questions that challenges businesses looking for IT solutions is whether to implement a WLAN managed by on-premises controllers, or one with controllers in the cloud? Which architecture would be more suitable? First of all, let's take a quick look at the evolution of WLAN networks, and then figure out the key differences between an on-premises WLAN and a cloud-managed one.

Autonomous Access Points

Trace back to the very beginning of WLAN design, each wireless access point was configured and managed independently from others. This way was not regarded as a problem at the time because most access points were deployed in specific areas such as meeting rooms or lobbies, and the number of devices connecting to Wi-Fi networks was few.

On-premises WLAN Controllers

With growing demand for wireless access in businesses, networking infrastructures also called for changes. Wireless signals had become a necessity within the entire building to meet demands; consequently hundreds of APs were deployed and managed. However, since these APs could not coordinate with each other, technical issues such as load-balance, channel selection, RF optimization and even to user authentication or client roaming, etc. might render the networks unstable or unpredictable.

To address these problems and control the massively deployed devices, wireless LAN controllers were created to force both control- and data-plane traffics to return to a single location for AP configuration, communication and even policy enforcement. Although on-premises WLAN controllers can greatly help administrators to manage multiple APs, it requires higher-skillset ITs to handle the complicated configuration tasks.

Cloud-managed WLAN Solution

In a cloud-managed WLAN architecture, organizations don't have to purchase physical controllers and deploy them on every site. The "cloud" mentioned here works like a virtual controller that actually reside in a public cloud, and all the distributed wireless access points connect to it via the Internet. The cloud offers remote provisioning, monitoring and troubleshooting to every access point.

Unlike hardware controller with higher upfront cost, the cloud-managed WLAN services, which are usually provided with an annual payment plan, give organizations more flexibility on their budgets comparing to on-premises ones, they are getting more popularity among organizations looking for centralized management and reduced costs. The cloud-managed WLAN services rely on subscribed licenses to work, and the cloud will take care of the issues such as data backup, storage, redundancy and more.

Benefits of On-premises and Cloud-managed WLAN Architectures

On-premises and cloud-based WLAN management approaches are both enterprise-ready now and they all have their own pros and cons, so determining which to implement depends on a number of factors. Before making the decision, you may want to have a look at the benefits of two architectures; let's get started with on-premises WLANs.

The Upside of On-premises Solutions
Relies less on Internet connectivity

Though there seems to be a big growth of cloud-managed architecture in the networking market, it's not for everyone. Cloud-controlled WLANs depend on the Internet to establish communications between wireless control data with local APs and to perform provision, authentication and other wireless services. The cloud-based functions could have problems to function properly if your Internet connectivity is spotty or suffers from latency and throughput issues.

On the contrary, an on-premises controller can handle all the functions locally without being affected by Internet issues.
Flexibility, robust WLAN access and failover

When it comes to actual network design and deployment, on-premises WLAN is considered more flexible and customizable under the most situations. On- premises solutions support more advanced features for Wi-Fi devices and applications, and they give administrators more granular control over specific wireless environments. In large, complex WLAN scenarios that deployed with hundreds of APs or need multiple network access authentication and authorization methods, on-premises controllers with role-based access control and secondary controller configuration can work together to offer more robust WLAN accessibility and failover support for users.

Advantages of Cloud-based Solutions
Ease of remote management and deployment

Cloud-managed design offers better management simplicity. In this architecture, there is no need to deploy controllers on each site. The cloud provides remote accessibility to control the entire network regardless of where the IT staff is located. One prerequisite of cloud-based WLAN solutions is that the cloud- managed networking hardware is designed for zero-touch deployments, so they can be installed without sending IT professionals on site. A tip to select cloud vendors, never go with anyone without zero-touch deployments as it lost one of the biggest benefits. The cloud-based approach makes networking deployments much easier – which is important especially for businesses with insufficient IT professionals.

No controller hardware limitations

Another obvious benefit of cloud-based WLANs is that the number of APs cloud can handle is unlimited, which provides better scalability in network deployment scenarios. So when it comes to expanding network infrastructures or setting up new sites, cloud-managed solutions can support from companies with just one AP in a single location up to multiple sites with hundreds of APs – all without the need to purchase additional hardware controllers.

Who Should Go for Cloud Then?

There is no definite choice between the two architectures as both can provide their respective benefits according to your company's current needs. So in what kind of situations should a business go for the cloud instead of staying on-premises? The following are some key criteria that might be helpful for you to make the decision on choosing cloud-based or on-premises solutions.

Is the network in your organization operated by limited IT staff?:

Start with taking a look over the IT structure in your organization. If you have IT staff that supports all branch locations and the team members are technical experts, then consider an on-premises solution as it offers a highly customizable network to fit your actual needs. However, if your IT team is relatively small and you are looking for an easy way to simplify deployment and management, then cloud- managed approach may be the best way to go.

Is your organization geographically distributed in multiple locations?:

On-premises architecture works well in large enterprise environments with sufficient technical support, while cloud-managed WLAN services are more suitable for distributed businesses with geographically dispersed branches such as retail chains with a large number of small sites. As cloud-managed access points can self-configure through the cloud, non-IT employees on the distributed sites just need to plug the devices in and turn them on, and then administrators can perform provision, monitoring and diagnostics from a remote location.

Has your organization dynamic demands?:

As cloud managed solutions require no hardware controllers, and no need to select from small or large controllers, while new APs can be added at any time to any location of any quantity. Cloud-managed WLAN services are based on the "pay as you grow" model that allows companies to pay for only what they need according to the companies' dynamics. Therefore, if organizations are experiencing uncertain demands in the nearly future, cloud-managed WLAN is a way to go as it would help them to deal with the problems.

Basically, on-premises solutions provide more advanced features and techniques for customized networking deployments as well as sophisticated management capabilities for administrators, while cloud-managed solutions provide ease of use, remote management and full network visibility. Consider what matters to you the most before going for either architecture.

Considerations of ZyXEL Nebula and NXC

Now you've learned about benefits of the two WLAN architectures and how'd they work with your company network and IT capabilities. No matter you go for cloud-managed services or on-premises wireless controllers, ZyXEL offers what is ideal for you to provide consistent, high-performance and secure wireless network services that support personal, guest and corporate-owned devices.

The ZyXEL NXC Wireless Controller Series and Gateway products with AP Controller functionality are capable of extending networks flexibly and fulfilling different deployment requirements with excellent compatibility. The ZyXEL Nebula Cloud Networking Solution can provide comprehensive control over Nebula devices across distributed locations through a single management interface.

Summary

Smart devices have changed the needs for WLAN networks. Today, offering secure, consistent and high-performance wireless network services are essential in every business. Fortunately, companies now have more options supporting the new requirements as some IT experts prefer the on-premises architecture, while some network engineers rave about the benefits of cloud networking. Just evaluate the current and near-future situation of your network, and then weight the factors listed above to see what is critical to your organization before making the best decision.

Gartner forecast: https://www.gartner.com/en/newsroom/press-releases/2019-08-29-gartner-says-5-8-billion-enterprise-and-automotive-io

Latest Press Release

Huawei unveils cutting edge technologies at Galileo 5G Online Live Tour and highlights global 5G trends

Huawei showcases three global trends for 5G at its Global Analyst Summit and the 5G Online Tour in Shenzhen, China: the transition from TDD-based Scaled Deployment to TDD+FDD Coordinated Deployment in order to meet bandwidth requirements of B2B...

AIS launches "GOMO", a 100% online SIM card, fit with lockdown ease. Allow Thais to live in the New Normal with fully online.

AIS is profoundly concerned and understands the lifestyles of customers and the public. Consequently, AIS is determined to develop solutions and create services designed to meet the new generation's lifestyles in the COVID-19 era to be convenient and...

Maintaining Business Continuity Amid Changing Workplace Operations

To address today’s concerns around public health and human safety, businesses across the globe are in the process of transitioning to a remote workforce. However, the sudden, widespread use of teleworker solutions has highlighted several challenges...

A helping hand in healthcare – collaborative robots

COVID-19, the global pandemic, took the world by surprise and suddenly the healthcare system has to confront one of the toughest challenges on a global scale. Healthcare workers are working round the clock and the intense workload at the frontline led...

Zyxel launches industry’s first five-color LED smart managed switch to help businesses adopt WiFi 6 standard with ease

Zyxel Networks, a leader in delivering secure, AI and cloud-powered home and business solutions, today launches the new XS1930 series 10/12-port Multi-Gigabit Smart Managed Switch, designed to help small and medium businesses achieve greater network...

Related Topics